Opens in a new tab

On This Day / November 20, 1971

Go Back

Reproduced with permission from The Irish News.

November 20, 2021

Publication Date

Image shows a thumbnail of a PDF of the Irish News page containing the Eamon Phoenix On This Day column dated 20th November 2021, detailing events reported on 20th November 1971

Summary: On This Day – 20th November 1971, the Compton Report acknowledged the physical ill-treatment of internees while rejecting allegations of brutality, prompting accusations of a whitewash and demands for further investigation. Edited by Éamon Phoenix.

‘White-wash’ Rejected | On This Day – 20th November 1971

THERE was ill-treatment of detainees during the internment operation here – but no physical brutality or cruelty, Sir Edmund Compton’s Committee of Inquiry reported yesterday.

The three-man team considered that techniques used in ‘questioning in depth’ constituted physical ill- treatment. These were:

Hooding: ‘a black pillow-slip’ which can increase a detainee’s sense of isolation…

Noise: a continuous and monotonous electronic ‘hissing’ or ‘mush’ noise… It may enhance the detainee’s sense of isolation.

Wall-standing: ‘Requiring detainees to stand with their arms against the wall for between four and six hours …”

Bread and water diet: ‘We found physical ill-treatment in the diet of one round of bread and one pint of water every six hours…’

Deprivation of sleep: ‘It was confirmed that it was the general policy to deprive the men of opportunity of sleep..’

However, in an introduction to the eighty-page document, the British Home Secretary, Mr Reginald Maudling, said the Government rejected any ‘suggestion that the methods currently authorised for interrogation contained any element of cruelty or brutality’.

But the Government had decided ‘it would be right to make arrangements for examining and providing authoritative advice for the interrogation of persons suspected of involvement in a terrorist campaign …’

Calls for International Inquiry into Techniques

THE Compton Report, with its admission of ill-treatment of detainees during interrogation, obviously gives little comfort to the British Government which is to review these procedures.

However, its inadequacies and word-spinning has drawn upon it from Opposition and outside spokesmen the general comment of being an exercise in white-washing the security forces.

Bishop William Philbin of Down and Connor said last night: ‘The facts revealed in the Compton Report are a serious indictment of the forces concerned…

I ask the responsible authorities to recognise that the indignation which such outrages provoke must be seen in conjunction with the increasingly common allegations of ill-treatment of civilians in the streets of Belfast’.

(Éamon Phoenix editor’s note: THE Compton Report followed an Investigation by a three-man commission into allegation of the brutal treatment of internees.

Dismissing allegations of brutality and torture, Compton found that there had been physical abuse and in-depth interrogation.

The cases of the ‘hooded men’ later went to the European Court of Human Rights which found Britain guilty of ‘inhuman and degrading treatment’.)

On This Day – 20th November 1971

Further Reading on Irish History:

List of other On This Day columns

Other resources: National Library of Ireland Irish News CAIN Archive

About Eamon Phoenix

About the Eamon Phoenix Foundation

On This Day is a daily column in the Irish News looking back either 50 or 100 years. The column was compiled by Dr Éamon Phoenix from the mid 1980s until autumn, 2022. The Foundation is very grateful to the Irish News for giving permission to reproduce Eamon’s columns. Funding gratefully received from Ireland’s Department of Foreign Affairs and the Magill Trust.

Visit Irish News

* The Foundation has worked hard to recreate Eamon’s distinctive voice through AI. Since this is an emerging technology, occasional imperfections may be audible.