Opens in a new tab

On This Day / November 17, 1921

Go Back

Reproduced with permission from The Irish News.

November 17, 2021

Publication Date

Image shows a thumbnail of a PDF of the Irish News page containing the Eamon Phoenix On This Day column dated 17th November 2021, detailing events reported on 17th November 1921

Summary: On This Day – 17th November 1921, James Craig rejected an all-Ireland parliament and proposed separate Dominion status for Northern Ireland, threatening peace negotiations as a man was wounded in Belfast. Edited by Éamon Phoenix.

Craig stands firm | On This Day – 17th November 1921

THE two outstanding events of the weekend were (1) the holding of a meeting of the Dáil Eireann Cabinet and (2) the announcement by Mr Milne Barbour [a Belfast industrialist], apparently with the authority of Craig that ‘the only concession Ulster could make would be to accept Dominion Home Rule for herself, but as a separate and distinct unit’.

Much importance is attached to the meeting of the National Unionist Association at Liverpool on Thursday when the vote on the Irish issue will largely decide Mr Lloyd George’s view as to the necessity of a general election.

Talks outlook ‘not promising’

AT a meeting in Derry on Friday night a resolution was adopted calling upon Sir James Craig and the members of his Cabinet to refuse to surrender any of the rights, privileges and liberties conferred upon the people of Northern Ireland by the Government of Ireland Act, 1920.

The Daily Chronicle [a Conservative organ] says: The Ulster Cabinet’s irrevocable opposition to an all-lreland parliament may have the gravest consequences.

There is grave disappointment in British Government circles for the situation is unpromising.

Mr Lloyd George’s policy is to go to the extreme limit of concession, and the country will expect the parties in Ireland to do the same in order that the kingdom may be spared the bitterness and ruin of civil war.

If the Irish negotiations break down – and at the moment it is, unfortunately, only too probable that they will – this will be followed by the immediate resignation of the Prime Minister and a general election.

Inspector stopped, man shot

ON the Glen Road, a Belfast suburb at the weekend a young man was wounded during a sensational hold-up of police officers by bodies of men.

The incident resulted in the wounding of a young man named Percy Bloomer of Clondara Street.

District Inspector Dudgeon of Lisburn was proceeding by motor with Sergeant Frazer when they came up to a body of men stated to number about 150.

The men spread across the road and called upon the district inspector to stop.

The officer put on full speed but one of the men jumped on the footboard.

A shot rang out from the car and the man fell on the roadway wounded.

(Éamon Phoenix editor’s note: Pressed by Lloyd George on November 10 1921 to accept an all-lreland Parliament, Craig not only rejected the idea but mischievously suggested that the north might become a separate dominion like Canada.

This idea was ejected by an angry Lloyd George as creating an unjustified hard border in Ireland. However, Craig knew he had Tory ‘diehard’ support for his stance.)

On This Day – 17th November 1921

Further Reading on Irish History:

List of other On This Day columns

Other resources: National Library of Ireland Irish News CAIN Archive

About Eamon Phoenix

About the Eamon Phoenix Foundation

On This Day is a daily column in the Irish News looking back either 50 or 100 years. The column was compiled by Dr Éamon Phoenix from the mid 1980s until autumn, 2022. The Foundation is very grateful to the Irish News for giving permission to reproduce Eamon’s columns. Funding gratefully received from Ireland’s Department of Foreign Affairs and the Magill Trust.

Visit Irish News

* The Foundation has worked hard to recreate Eamon’s distinctive voice through AI. Since this is an emerging technology, occasional imperfections may be audible.